KINDLE VS IPAD
Posted on May 5th, 2010 by Bob and Joy Schwabach
Around 2.5 million Kindles have been sold in the last two and a half years. One million iPads have been sold in a little over a month. Which is better as an e-Reader?
Top 11 Arguments for the Kindle
- The “3G” wireless connection on the Kindle is free. You don’t have to be in a Wi-Fi hotspot to download books, or shell out an extra $100 for a 3G version of the Kindle.
- The Kindle gives you free sample chapters on any book in their 500,000 book library.
- The Kindle lets you look up words, highlight passages and make notes (and in a few weeks, you’ll be able to share passages with friends) without leaving your book.
- Blogs are faster to get through when you have a list of headlines and no distracting graphics.
- You can get Kindle tech support any hour of the day or night.
- You can read the Kindle in bright sunlight.
- The Kindle charges faster.
- You’re not forever having to clean the Kindle screen.
- The Kindle is cheaper.
- The Kindle is lighter. Hold it aloft in one hand while lying on the couch.
- The Kindle is easier on your eyes than the iPad is, if you’re reading a book or long article.
Top 11 Arguments for the iPad
- Glorious color.
- Newspapers and magazines have videos accompanying their stories.
- Blogs are more useful when you can click on their links.
- The Wall Street Journal app is gorgeous, and lets you look at a “now” edition, which is up to the minute. It lets you save individual stories or sections.
- USA Today and the New York Times “Editor’s Choice,” look just like the real newspaper.
- You can play your iTunes collection while running a slideshow of your photos.
- You can read the iPad in the dark.
- You can easily see graphs and charts without the zoom feature that isn’t available yet on the Kindle.
- The touchscreen is a joy to use.
- The 3G version has GPS, so you can find out where you are.
- Besides being an e-Reader, there are endless apps for games, email, social networking, productivity tools, TV shows and movies.

A really interesting comparison. Isn’t the big question “Is the iPad an e-Reader?” and, fundamentally, the answer is “No”. Item 10 on the iPad list tells us that it is something else entirely – more of an Media-Reader.
When it comes to reading a novel the iPad is going to be very hard work. However, I don’t see why a new form of literature couldn’t be created by the iPad. Including interactive maps, photos & video in a crime novel or thriller would be very exciting and the Kindle (and it’s like) are never going to be doing that.
Paul
Check out the “Vook,” video-book, at vook.com. I’ve been reading the free Sherlock Holmes Vook on my iPad but you can also read them on a computer. Videos accompany the stories, telling us something about the author and the setting.
I agree that the iPad has huge potential in interactivity.
Thanks for your comment!
-Joy Schwabach